As teenagers rethink school and profession choices, counselors try to adapt


This story was initially revealed by Chalkbeat. Join their newsletters at

When college students come into Danielle Insel’s school and profession advising workplace with their sights set on larger schooling, she has a guidelines of subsequent steps prepared. For years, round 9 out of 10 children fell into that camp, she estimates.

However lately, a rising variety of seniors–upwards of 30 p.c, she guesses–have instructed her they don’t have any intention of going to varsity. And extra children than ever are contemplating methods to generate profits with no school diploma, Insel stated–pushed partially by individuals and jobs they’ve encountered on social media. For these college students, there’s no equal guidelines.

Insel has one scholar this 12 months decided to be a tattoo artist. However after researching potential commerce college choices and discovering nothing inexpensive, Insel — the postsecondary readiness counselor at City Meeting Institute of Math and Science for Younger Ladies in downtown Brooklyn — stated they got here up with a plan for the scholar to go to tattoo parlors and ask in the event that they’d take her on as an apprentice. Thus far, one has invited her again for a extra in-depth dialog.

The shift in Insel’s workplace is just not an remoted case.

The pandemic profoundly reshaped the school and profession panorama for highschool graduates in New York Metropolis and throughout the nation. And the advisors who advise them have needed to change their strategy in response.

The speed of metropolis college students enrolling in some type of larger schooling inside six months of commencement fell from 81% in 2019 to 71% in 2021 — the bottom fee since no less than 2007, in response to metropolis knowledge. Nationwide, 62% of current highschool graduates enrolled in school in 2022, down from 66% in 2019, in response to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. 

That drop mixed with the rising curiosity in non-college choices has spurred counselors like Insel who’ve traditionally centered totally on pushing college students towards school to spend extra effort and time serving to college students navigate the world of labor and commerce college.

“I’ve modified my language to, ‘I’m not right here to push school on anybody, there are many completely different pathways,’” stated Insel. 

That shift in language mirrors one throughout your complete New York Metropolis Training Division, which went from touting a program referred to as “School Entry For All” a number of years in the past, to pushing a brand new initiative centered on “career-connected studying” and a number of “pathways.” 

Roughly 100 excessive faculties throughout the town are getting cash by the brand new FutureReadyNYC initiative to roll out profession and technical schooling programs, and hundreds of scholars are taking part in paid internships or apprenticeships.

“What you’re seeing all throughout the nation, this concept that everyone’s simply selling school, school, school … There’s received to be one other approach and one other monitor and one other pathway for teenagers to achieve success,” faculties Chancellor David Banks beforehand instructed Chalkbeat.

Serving to college students with detailed post-graduation plans

In some ways, that’s a welcome change, counselors stated. Beforehand, Insel generally felt the singular concentrate on school may very well be alienating and make some college students “upset and scared and confused.” It might additionally push some college students who weren’t prepared into school, main them to drop out and wind up with debt, not levels.

At the same time as many counselors welcome the brand new acceptance of non-college pathways, it presents some challenges.

Some counselors nonetheless fear in regards to the availability of long-term, economically-secure life paths for his or her non-college certain children.

Nearly all of new jobs posted in New York Metropolis require a bachelor’s diploma, and there are nonetheless cussed disparities throughout a spread of life outcomes – together with a rising hole in life expectancy – between People with a school schooling and people with out.

Furthermore, the roadmap for how you can finest assist children bored with school is commonly much less clear than for his or her college-bound friends, counselors stated.

Educators in New York Metropolis really feel “overwhelmed” by protecting monitor of the numerous packages throughout the 5 boroughs for college kids trying to enter the workforce with no school diploma, in response to a September report from School Entry: Analysis and Motion, which carried out in-depth interviews with educators from 9 metropolis faculties.

A number of counselors who spoke to Chalkbeat lamented the shortage of inexpensive, high quality commerce college choices for current highschool graduates, and stated the few packages they’ve historically relied on, just like the Coop Tech program run by the town Training Division, have gotten tougher for college kids to get into as demand has grown.

For Adeola Alexander, a veteran school counselor at Kurt Hahn Expeditionary Studying Excessive College in Flatbush, Brooklyn, the problem lies in putting the proper steadiness between supporting college students’ rapid objectives, pursuits and financial wants, and searching for his or her long-term prospects.

“As soon as younger individuals begin to work, that’s a very good factor,” she stated. “However the cash you make at 16 is just not sustainable for you once you’re 26. …  I simply need to make sure that when college students are being uncovered to careers and jobs that there’s a long-term plan for them.”

Training Division officers say they’re planning to make sure by 2030 that each highschool graduate – college-bound or not – leaves college with an in depth plan of their subsequent steps.

“If you consider how briskly the world is altering, and the completely different sorts of occupations and careers,” Jade Grieve, the Training Division’s Chief of Pupil Pathways, lately instructed reporters, “that’s deep, arduous work.”

College students dealing with a brand new school actuality

Counselors stated a variety of elements drove down school enrollment in the course of the pandemic.

Many college students disengaged from college throughout distant studying, and got here again “just a little bit disillusioned with college-going,” stated Alexander.

Different teenagers had members of the family who misplaced jobs, and felt further strain to generate profits – placing the concept of faculty briefly out of the query, counselors stated.

Nonetheless others had been frightened by the prospect of attending any in-person lessons whereas COVID-19 was spreading, or had been deterred by vaccine mandates at faculties, counselors stated.

It’s clear that the pandemic wasn’t the one pressure driving the decline in school enrollment.

College students in New York Metropolis, like these throughout the nation, have lengthy been involved in regards to the potential dangers of scholar debt and whether or not investments in larger schooling will repay, counselors stated. And a few educators stated they noticed these worries escalate in recent times because the nationwide dialog on the scholar debt disaster intensified.

“Completely I’ve seen extra college students speaking about debt and speaking about both individuals they know or individuals they’ve seen on social media who’ve taken out a whole lot of debt and couldn’t pay it,” stated Alexander.

The youngsters almost certainly to fall off the school monitor had been those that would possibly’ve in previous years attended group faculties, which provide two-year packages and enroll larger shares of Black, Latino and college students from low-income backgrounds, knowledge suggests.

There are indicators of a modest rebound this 12 months. After years of enrollment declines, the Metropolis College of New York, by far the most well-liked vacation spot for New York Metropolis public highschool graduates, noticed a slight uptick on this 12 months’s freshman class in contrast with final 12 months.

Some faculties like Insel’s require all college students, even these sure they received’t attend, to submit purposes for CUNY.

Town Training Division launched an initiative this 12 months to ship a CUNY acceptance letter to each highschool graduate within the hopes that having a bodily letter in hand could give college students who had been on the fence the additional enhance they should enroll.

Alexander, the counselor in Flatbush, patiently walks her college students by a thicket of misconceptions in regards to the economics of faculty, explaining that it’s typically possible to work and attend college on the similar time, like she did. Most college students who attend CUNY, furthermore, graduate with no debt, and in some circumstances, taking over a small quantity of debt could be a accountable monetary resolution, when it’s more likely to reap long-term positive aspects, she tells college students.

Alexander’s work with college students typically continues after they graduate. Yearly, she will get a trickle of scholars returning to her workplace as a result of they’re excited by restarting school after dropping out or enrolling for the primary time.

Counselors navigate the world of labor

Postsecondary counselors searching for to advise college students who don’t plan on attending school typically need to navigate a world of labor the place the steps are much less clear, and the assets extra scattered, than they’re for college kids pursuing larger schooling. 

For a lot of college students, commerce college can appear to be a logical first step. However discovering commerce faculties which are inexpensive and vetted for high quality is commonly a problem, counselors stated.

“I do battle nonetheless with serving to college students discover what I need to say is viable commerce college choices,” stated Alexander.

Many commerce packages don’t provide their very own monetary help, and will not settle for the identical state and federal help as faculties, counselors stated. 

And whereas faculties are required to offer public info on prices, completion charges, and long-term work outcomes for his or her graduates, that info may be tougher to search out for commerce and vocational packages.

On this vein, the September report from School Entry: Analysis and Motion acknowledged that “educators are rightfully asking in regards to the return on funding of the options which are being provided.” 

Counselors guiding a scholar instantly into a particular line of labor can really feel further strain to know the economics of that trade, for the reason that scholar received’t have the flexibleness that comes with a school diploma.

Jasmine Benzvi, a counselor at Queens Metropolitan Expeditionary Studying College in Forest Hills, stated it’s a part of her job to maintain up with “what’s taking place within the job market, the place the roles are going, and which fields pay properly.” However she acknowledged it’s “not doable to be an professional on all of these issues.”

A number of counselors pointed to a different issue that could be swaying college students’ views on whether or not they want larger schooling.

“I truthfully imagine TikTok and social media has proven our college students can earn cash in quite a lot of methods with no school diploma,” stated Insel.

College students excited by cosmetology, for instance, who see on-line influencers being profitable from hair and make-up tutorials, may even see it as a extra viable path, Insel stated. 

Insel stated she’s began trying into the economics of a profession as a social media influencer so she will have extra concrete info to share with children.

“I’ve undoubtedly needed to be taught alongside the way in which,” she stated.

Michael Elsen-Rooney is a reporter for Chalkbeat New York, protecting NYC public faculties. Contact Michael at

Chalkbeat is a nonprofit information web site protecting instructional change in public faculties.

Associated: Extra highschool grads are rejecting 4-year pathways

Newest posts by eSchool Media Contributors (see all)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *